toddgarland.com

Essay · · 7 min

What Happens When Creativity Becomes Abundant?

As creation gets cheaper, scarcity moves to taste, judgment, trust, and follow-through.

By Todd Garland

For most of history, imagination was abundant. Execution was not.

People have always had ideas. Stories, designs, products, arguments, songs, inventions, better ways of doing things. What was scarce was the ability to give those ideas form. Turning imagination into reality required time, skill, tools, coordination, money, and usually other people. Much of what people imagined stayed invisible because production was expensive.

That shaped more than output. It shaped culture itself.

When making is hard, fewer people get to participate. Fewer ideas survive long enough to become visible. Fewer experiments make it into the world. Scarcity acts as a filter, even when no one intends it to. A lot of culture has been shaped by that simple fact: creation used to be costly enough that friction did much of the curating for us.

That is what feels like it is changing now.

We are entering a world where the cost of creation is falling fast enough to change behavior at scale. Not to zero, and not evenly across every domain, but enough that more people can make more things more often. A lot of the current conversation still treats AI as a productivity tool, and that is true as far as it goes. But productivity is what this feels like from the inside. Abundance is what it looks like from the outside once millions of people begin using the same leverage at once.

What is becoming abundant is the ability to get off zero. To give an idea enough form that you can react to it, test it, and decide what comes next. A finished product still demands much more. But many more ideas can now reach that first tangible stage.

History has seen versions of this before. The printing press lowered the cost of reproducing thought. Photography lowered the cost of making images. The internet lowered the cost of publishing to the world. Each time, the result was not just more output. It was wider participation, weaker old filters, new forms of noise, and a shift in what became scarce.

The medium changed, but the pattern did not.

When creativity becomes abundant, society gets more of almost everything: more writing, more design, more prototypes, more software, more products, more experiments, more videos, more arguments, more weird side projects, and more unfinished attempts. More people get to participate in the act of making. That is not a side effect.

It is one of the main events.

For a long time, many people lived at a distance from creation. They had ideas, opinions, instincts, and taste, but the path from “I wish this existed” to “I made something” was too long, too technical, too expensive, or too dependent on permission. As those barriers fall, more people get to step onto the field. More people get to test their own ideas against reality. More people get to discover whether they are builders.

That is a real gain.

I can feel it in my own work. Right now, I am moving between roughly fifteen projects across software, physical products, and things that need to be manufactured. So many ideas feel worth pursuing that committing to one has become its own challenge.

One of those projects is a Bitcoin clock. It has brought me back to 3D printing for the first time since Great American Mining. At one point, we had forty printers running at once, a whole room dedicated to making custom parts for our mobile data centers. I was not hands-on with that part of the business, but it fascinated me. I wanted to explore it myself someday.

Now I am using AI to work in CAD and develop product prototypes. Alongside that, I am working on audience.is for BuySellAds and other small projects. The range of things I can meaningfully attempt has expanded across disciplines.

I have more unfinished ideas than I have ever had before. My capacity to begin has expanded much faster than my capacity to commit.

That is one small, personal consequence of abundance.

Across society, abundance produces more of everything. More signal, yes, but also more noise. More originality, but also more imitation. More insight, but also more plausible mediocrity. More finished work, but also far more things that look finished before they have been deeply considered.

When the barriers to creation fall, participation rises. And when participation rises, the world becomes more energetic, more inventive, more expressive, and much harder to parse.

Abundance never eliminates scarcity. It relocates it.

That is the main idea I keep coming back to.

As giving ideas form becomes easier, more of the difficulty moves into deciding what deserves attention, what earns trust, and what is worth carrying forward. Scarcity moves downstream. It moves into taste, judgment, trust, curation, resonance, persistence, and follow-through.

If more people can make something that looks good, taste matters more.

If more people can publish, trust matters more.

If more people can prototype, judgment matters more.

If more people can start, finishing matters more.

If more people can flood the world with output, resonance becomes harder to earn.

Some experiments earn their place through what they teach us. They never need to become products. But the things we want other people to use have another threshold to cross: they have to matter enough to those people to become part of their lives.

That is not depressing to me. It is clarifying.

It means the future will not belong simply to the people who can produce. It will belong increasingly to the people who can navigate abundance. The people who can tell the difference between friction removed and value created. The people who know how to use easier creation not just to make more things, but to make better choices. The people who can find signal in noise, refine rather than just generate, and keep standards high in a world that makes average output cheap.

The first-order effect is obvious: more gets made.

The second-order effect is more interesting: standards change.

When rough drafts get cheaper, refinement becomes the expectation. When trying gets cheaper, experimentation becomes the expectation. When more people can make more things, good enough starts to feel less good enough.

Cheap creation raises the bar.

Not because quality becomes automatic, but because the baseline moves.

I think the bar for adoption is rising with it. A great idea or a well-made product can still ask too much of someone. Another account. Another workflow. Another place to move information. Another thing to remember. For a physical product, it might be a new habit, a place in the home, or a different way of doing something familiar.

Something can be impressive and still fail to fit.

With audience.is, the purpose is to help newsletter publishers turn information about their audiences into reports for sponsors. It has to improve that work enough to earn its place.

The conversation about “AI slop” only gets us so far. The harder competition includes things that are thoughtful, useful, and well made. More of those things can exist too. The standard becomes how well something understands and serves the person using it.

One possible outcome is a world with many more small, specific products. Broad products ask people with different needs to work within a shared design. As creation gets cheaper, it may become practical to make more things around the particular way a smaller group wants something to work.

A tool for one kind of work. An object shaped around one preference. Something that fits a small community, a household, or just the person who made it.

Whether through new products, customization, or people building for themselves, more things could become worth making without needing to become useful to everyone. How far that goes is still an open question.

That makes judgment more important. Knowing who something is for. Knowing what to leave out. Knowing which ideas deserve to become experiments, and which deserve the sustained effort of becoming something people rely on.

So what happens when creativity becomes abundant?

I think a society becomes more inventive. More expressive. More experimental. More competitive. More surprising. It also becomes noisier, more crowded, and more demanding. It asks more of our judgment, more of our standards, and more of our ability to decide what is worth building, sharing, trusting, and carrying forward.

That is the world I think we are entering.

Not a world with less creativity, but a world with so much creativity that the real challenge is no longer unlocking it.

The real challenge is knowing what to do with all of it.

← Thinking out loud